Adobe 10 Years Behind Webtrends

March 26th, 2012

Topics: Featured, Perspectives

Recently, I was perusing technology news when I came across a curious press release entitled, “Adobe Adds Cross-Visit Analytics to Digital Marketing Suite for Deeper Insight Into the Visitor Experience”.

Now, being a CEO of a company competing in this space, someone who is deeply passionate about solving the challenges faced by contemporary digital marketers and someone who has (for better or worse) been in the industry longer than almost anyone today (with the possible exception of Mr. Peterson, who was a web site developer at Webtrends prior to my joining), I thought that this was going to be some very interesting reading.

Had our venerable competitor cracked a pesky problem that has befuddled our industry since the dawn of Netscape?  Had they uncovered the holy grail of digital marketing—the ability to tie together a single person’s activities over time, place and behavior—that was so ruthlessly impeded when the internet came into being due to anonymity, technology limitations, multiple data collection methodologies and the fundamental inability to determine the “who” while honoring privacy concerns?  Had they truly realized complete and clear personal attribution?

In a word: no.  In three words: not even close.

Actually, I was mightily disappointed and even somewhat shocked by the contents of Adobe’s press release.  Not only had they NOT found a new way to resolve an age-old problem, but they were making a splash about an approach that has been in place for more than a decade—the ability to connect one person’s behavior to the same website over multiple visits. 

This is kid’s stuff, people!  The engineers and innovators here at Webtrends have been delivering on that approach for more than a decade!  To put that into perspective, if Al Gore’s presidential campaign had been using Webtrends and wanted to know if somebody knocked twice on their digital door, we could’ve given them the answer back in the year 2000!

What’s truly disappointing about Adobe’s announcement is not that they’re trumpeting a ten-year old capability as a new function, but that they’ve been selling it in the marketplace for that same period of time.  It’s almost like Chevy announcing, “The new Corvette!  Now with seatbelts!”  I find Adobe’s announcement confusing at best, disingenuous at worst and misleading no matter how you slice it.  After all, if this is in fact a new feature, then what have their customers been receiving for the millions of dollars directed toward their solutions these past ten years?

The sad fact is that not only is the approach announced by Adobe seriously old news, but the market’s needs have moved significantly beyond this simple, out of the box feature.  Today, Webtrends delivers on the ability to tie together a single person’s activities over multiple visits to a web site, a mobile site, a mobile application and a Facebook application.  AND we take it a step further to tie together that individual’s activity over multiple sets of those locations—over time, place and behavior.

Our immediate product roadmap includes the ability to drive real time analysis in each of these areas as well as the ability to leverage the behavioral knowledge derived from these successive visits over time and target content and information specific to that visitor’s scored affinity.  As we stand today Webtrends is already delivering on real-time relevance and personalization in web and mobile channels and are actively driving it into our social roadmap.

We call it Webtrends Real Time Relevance.  The core pillars of which are real time, customer-centric, across channel and open to allow you to leverage this information in any CRM, CMS, On-site Search, eCommerce, or Collaboration solutions.

Given Adobe’s announcement of a ten-year old feature, it appears that they’re certainly not focused on reacting to the contemporary digital marketer’s real-time needs, or doing it in a relevant way.  Put down your StarTAC phones people, turn off Ally McBeal and join us in the 21st century!

Alex Yoder

About the Author

CEO

As chief executive officer, Alex Yoder is responsible for worldwide operations and the overall strategic vision of Webtrends. During his tenure at Webtrends, he has successfully worked to expand the brand and deliver business value to global enterprises. His time at Webtrends tops off more than 20 years of global business experience spanning leadership roles across sales, marketing and operations. Alex won a Stevie Award for Executive of the Year in Computer Software at the 2011 American Business Awards and was recognized by the Portland Business Journal as the 2010 CEO of the Year in Technology.

  • Ash

    Way to miss the point, Alex. This press release wasn’t even about product features. Adobe are getting their name into busy news sites, along with words like “innovative” (even if that doesn’t really apply in this case). Business decision makers, who might sign lucrative contracts for Omniture, will see that association. 

  • http://twitter.com/RalfHaberich Ralf Haberich

    I like your testosterone driven discussion about features and work experience. Unprofessional, but funny.

    http://www.web-analytics-blog.de

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Nikolaj-Bardram/657531637 Nikolaj Bardram

    Personally I would much rather see webtrends blog about their own improvements, rather than bad mouthing their competitors. As an ex consultant dealing primarily with webtrends, and now as web analyst working only with webtrends, I have never found the need to talk about the competitors, because webtrends as a product in the hands of the right person can do amazing things which sells the product by itself.

  • Gary

    Disappointing, as your response is quite cocky.  Sometimes the highroad is the best route.

  • http://webtrends.com Webtrends

    Rand, thanks so much for your
    comments and insights.  You are correct—I neglected to mention one of the
    longest tenured members of our community, Rand Schulman.  There are many
    others, such as Andrew Edwards, Jim Sterne (with whom you so kindly initiated the
    Web Analytics Association, of which I am proud to be a board member).
     It’s been more than 25% of my life that’s been dedicated to helping
    organizations and individuals see the truth of the value and insight that can
    be derived from their digital properties.  I’ve seen a lot of false claims
    and misdirected expectations over the years.  My comments come from a deep
    sense of knowledge and commitment to honesty and openness.  Our customers
    can expect that and I believe that this is the set of values that you were
    excited to represent in your phenomenal keynote.

    -Alex Yoder

     

  • Andrew Edwards

    Despite its causing a kerfuffle about who’s got more experience in what is now called “digital analytics”, I believe there is an underlying truth in Alex’s claim that Adobe huffs and puffs about features that are all fine and serviceable but not necessarily trendsetting.

    Its just that for numerous interface and marketing reasons, Adobe’s Omniture has become the pay-vendor of choice for what seems a large majority of marketers; few of them having to do with its actual superiority to Webtrends. Some of this no doubt due to agressive, almost evangelical-style promotion.

    Many practitioners know there is more likely parity in the major analytics tools for most analytics purposes. Yet I have heard from several very technical folks who know both tools, that at the top end of customizability, it is Webtrends that holds the advantage.

  • http://www.schulmanthorogood.com/ Rand Schulman

    Well Alex, I hate to disagree with you, but I think I’ve been around even longer than you and Eric (97 as CEO of Keylime)! My partner Pelin,  from the Schulman + Thorogood Group, and I keynoted at the recent eMetrics event in SF, and we showcased your technology in our presentation – Creating a Metrics Driven Social Demand Generation Program http://slidesha.re/GDHoOU . Yes, it’s truly cool stuff and ahead of its time, and I believe better than Adobe.

    • http://webtrends.com Webtrends

       Above comment was edited for clarification at author’s request.